Mike Knott

WATERCOOLER: Do our jobless need more than welfare?

THE mental health of the unemployed deteriorates the longer they are out of work and this is a barrier to securing future employment, research has found.

While different ways to reach this group are being trialled, no solution is firmly in sight.

The connection between unemployment and mental illness was most visible during the global financial crisis when Australia's economic growth slowed and unemployment and underemployment increased.

Suicide rates among the unemployed rose 22% during the crisis compared to their rates prior to the crisis.
 

DOES MORE NEED TO BE DONE TO HELP THE UNEMPLOYED?

ARE WELFARE PAYMENTS ENOUGH?

Let us know in the comments below
 

There is still an estimated 727,500 Australians out of work and a notable lack of interventions addressing the mental health needs of the unemployed.

There are likely several explanations for why the unemployed miss out on programs that could improve their mental health.
 

Chris Ison

The first reason is that some of the main adopters of workplace mental health activities have been employers with no long-term obligation to provide help to the people they have let go.

If employers aren't responsible for the mental health of the unemployed as they search for work, it would seem to fall into the remit of government employment services.

However, while governmental services have regular contact with job seekers and require them participate in a Job Plan in order to receive benefits, there appears to be a lack of attention to the mental health impacts of unemployment itself.
 

WHAT YOU'RE SAYING ON FACEBOOK:

Sue Sanders
Maybe instead of wasting time in Parliament trying to play 'Gotcha' with each other, our politicians should come up with some ways to get our economy out of the toilet. Supporting small business will give Australians more opportunity for jobs and then we will not need to be a drain on our welfare system.

Chris Bourke
Maybe swap 50% of their payment for vouchers, and put the money into a compulsory employment training program for minimum of 10 hours per week to give them skills to get a job. The vouchers is a good incentive to look for a job if they want more cash, and 10 hours a week to hone your skills is nothing when you don't have a job to go to. There are jobs everywhere, they just need to be encouraged.

Mark Johnson
I've been unemployed for 3 1/2 years. Employers and labour hire firms won't even bother to look at my resume because of that. The jobactive 'service' is nothing more than a sick joke that treats the unemployed as commodities and does nothing to help in finding work. I honestly don't know how much more I can take.

Shane Merman Richter
Makes me sad when it's an entry level job and they want experience .... Change that and ALOT will change I think

Cheyenne Girdham
Been looking for a job for 3-4 years now no one will give the experience. I recently moved for better work opitunities still no luck i need the money to pay rent,etc.

Lorraine Arndt
By putting the retiring age up to 66 younger people can't get job think about it it is harder on elderly people doing manual work and when too much they have to go on dole and go find a new job at 60 years of age and older give us a break


Some people who have a mental illness end up in a catch 22 scenario where difficulties in job seeking exacerbate mental health issues and this in turn might make it difficult to apply for jobs.

These difficulties include accessing transport to and from work, negative attitudes of employers and co-workers and concern about how to balance employment with treatment for ongoing health problems.

There is also a changing landscape of government requirements regarding access to financial support.

For example, people with a disability may be asked to undertake an Job Capacity Assessment, which has flow-on implications for a person's ability to access the Disability Support Pension.
 

Darryn Smith

A second reason for the lack of attention to the mental health of the unemployed is that they are harder to engage than those who are employed (who can be identified and contacted in a work setting). This poses a challenge to face-to-face and group-based interventions addressing mental health.

Online interventions have been shown to be beneficial for those people suffering from mental health problems. Recognising this, the government launched an e-Mental Health Strategy in 2014.

The importance of electronic interventions has also recently been emphasised in the Australian government's 2015 response to a review of mental health services.

Online interventions may be the most feasible option for the unemployed population, who otherwise may be difficult to reach or to engage face-to-face. There are some current trials that aim to boost the mental health of job seekers using online approaches.

For example, a program from Incolink and Deakin University called "Contact & Connect" is providing online mental health support for the unemployed via a series of text messages sent from a website.

The program is designed to give unemployed people tools to look after their mental wellbeing.

Are we doing enough to help Australia's unemployed?

This poll ended on 10 March 2016.

Current Results

No, what we need is for people to be less lazy

29%

Yes, most people want to do the work. They just need an opportunity

65%

Payments from Centrelink should be enough

5%

This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

 

The long-term goal of the trial is to break down stigma against help-seeking and encourage social interaction with friends and family.

While this approach shows promise because it can be delivered remotely and conveniently, it does not yet have results.

It's also important to remember that online programs such as "Contact & Connect" are not meant to be undertaken at the exclusion of other treatments. Ideally, online intervention would operate hand-in-hand with face-to-face treatment.

At the end of the day, there maybe no one-size fits all approach to helping those who are unemployed back on the road to recovery.

Tackling this problem will be complex, and likely necessitate involvement from multiple stakeholders including affected individuals, families, employers, support services, government, and others.

Despite this, greater attention to the topic is needed given the large impact of job loss on an individual's life, and the subsequent flow-on effects to mental health and wellbeing.
 

Allison Milner is the deputy director of the Work, Health and Wellbeing Unit, Population Health Strategic Research Centre at Deakin University

 

This article appears courtesy of The Conversation



"Someone could have been injured or killed"

premium_icon "Someone could have been injured or killed"

An RFS crew sheltered in their truck as the grass fire overcame them

How this Ballina mum juggles kids and a thriving business

premium_icon How this Ballina mum juggles kids and a thriving business

"Kids are amazing but... having a passion is fulfilling as well”

Local Partners