News

Rous head ‘should resign’ over fluoride, says campaigner

Anti-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack
Anti-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack Jacklyn Wagner

ANTI-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack has called on the head of Rous Water to resign over confusion around the question of a legal requirement to fluoridate the region's water supply.

Mr Oshlack said instead of chasing him to pay the estimated $300,000 in costs awarded to Rous following his loss in the NSW Court of Appeal last month on his bid to stop the construction of five fluoride-dousing plants, Rous general manager Kyme Lavelle should quit.

Mr Oshlack said his opinion was that Mr Lavelle had a moral and ethical responsibility to resign.

His comment came yesterday after he had decided not to appeal the case further.

However, Mr Lavelle responded by telling The Northern Star he took his position seriously and stood by the process Rous followed.

"Council acted in accordance with legal advice which covered a range of issues including directions and

How The Northern Star broke the story of Rous councillors who were told they could face legal action if they voted against fluoridation.
How The Northern Star broke the story of Rous councillors who were told they could face legal action if they voted against fluoridation.

approvals from the State Government," he said.

"Only part of that advice was challenged and council successfully defended four out of five grounds of appeal.

"The one ground on which council was not successful was held by the court not to have any consequence for the validity of council's assessment and decision-making process."

Mr Lavelle tabled the legal advice just before councillors voted on fluoridation in April 2010. Chairman Philip Silver used his casting vote to pass the motion five to four.

Voting intentions changed dramatically following the tabling of the advice that said councillors would be personally liable for fines until fluoridation was approved.

At the time councillor David Yarnall, who changed his vote based on the advice, said: "I find this extremely distressing as it takes away our democratic rights. I unfortunately feel we have no alternative at this stage."

While the NSW Appeals court found against the bid to stop the plants, it did find the legal advice was erroneous, but it didn't invalidate the vote by Rous councillors.

Topics:  fluoride rous water



A to Z of Woolworths Marvel Heroes Super Discs

Woolworths Marvel Heroes Super Discs are the latest craze in collectables.

What is Woolworths latest collectable craze about?

Man flamed after labelling Byron Bay single girls 'stuck up'

Single man flamed on social media after labelling Byron Bay women 'loopy'.

"Most of the girls here are ... very stuck up, or just not right.

Comedy production hits Rochdale stage

Thoroughly relishing their roles as the three crotchety old veterans (performed by Co Gray Wilson, Jason Smith and John Taylor), they provide fascinating individual insights into three proud men who despite their frailties are determined be adventurous and joyful to the end.

Heroes is a comedy play by Gerald Sibleyras.

Local Partners

Book review: Mia Freedman's book meets her critics head on

IF AUSTRALIA does have a tall poppy syndrome, Mia Freedman has most certainly been a victim.

Comedy production hits Rochdale stage

Thoroughly relishing their roles as the three crotchety old veterans (performed by Co Gray Wilson, Jason Smith and John Taylor), they provide fascinating individual insights into three proud men who despite their frailties are determined be adventurous and joyful to the end.

Heroes is a comedy play by Gerald Sibleyras.

Stan our man for Archibald Prize

Stan Gilchrist in front of the portrait  East Ballina artist Brett Belot will enter in the Archibald Prize later this year.

Local face to be entered in prestigious national art prize

Mandy and Ellen will be just women like us in Nimbin

DUO: Mandy Nolan and Ellen Briggs bring their hit show Women Like Us to Nimbin.

Hit comedy show heading towards Nimbin

Chicago comes to Bangalow

CELL BLOCK TANGO: Actress Catherine Zeta-Jones in a scene from the 2002 film Chicago.

The next production by Bangalow Theatre Company

Model Bella Hadid's see-through dress shocks in Cannes

US model Bella Hadid attends the Cinema Against AIDS amfAR gala 2017 held at the Hotel du Cap, Eden Roc in Cap d'Antibes, France, 25 May 2017.

It’s like she’s become addicted to shock value.

Here's your chance to carp about feral pests

Carp might by great fun to catch but they're destroying Australia's watercourses.

Science in the Pub looks at carp and coral trees

SNEAK PEEK: What new shopping centre is going to look like

Artist impression of the proposed redevelopment of the cinema and shopping complex on Jonson St, Byron Bay.

Mercato billed as regional NSW's most sustainable shopping complex

How Toowoomba house prices compare in Australia

For sale sign in front of home.

Here's what $700,000 will buy you in Toowoomba, Brisbane and Sydney

Slaves in Byron: The dark side of housing crisis

Housing generic.

A darker side to Byron's economy

Bonville to become new housing hub

REZONING: Large areas of Bonville have been rezoned for residential

Land rezoning will turn farmland into housing

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!