The NRL and the Cronulla Sharks have acted harshly towards Todd Carney.
The NRL and the Cronulla Sharks have acted harshly towards Todd Carney. Griffith Thomas

NRL gives Todd Carney the rough end

THE vast majority of people don't want or need to know that Todd Carney was photographed in a "lewd act".

Maybe a couple of thousand of Carney's 40,000 Twitter followers would have accidentally seen the photo - and there are always those who seek out such things (myself included).

But it was the media that ensured millions, not thousands, of people would know about this photograph - and it is Cronulla Sharks who are guilty of overreacting to it.

How does it benefit anyone to know about this photo? Why do people care?

Why do we get our knickers in a knot over a stupid photo and then drop the ball when something happens that actually matters?

Todd Carney's career is in tatters, but lining up for the North Queensland Cowboys every weekend is Robert Lui.

He was banned from the game for a year after kicking and head-butting his girlfriend in 2012.

Former Cronulla winger Isaac Gordon received a nine-match ban for pushing his heavily pregnant girlfriend against a wall in 2011.

Neither of those men was sacked from his club, or embarrassed and shamed the way Todd Carney has been embarrassed and shamed.

In fact, at the time North Queensland issued a statement saying the club would support Lui's ongoing counselling with a view to him returning to the team during the next season.

I bet most people don't even remember these men being in the press, but everyone will remember Carney's faux pas.

I see the message the NRL is sending. Clearly it's a far greater crime to indulge in a silly prank than to assault a woman.



Why this businessman is disgusted by rate debate

premium_icon Why this businessman is disgusted by rate debate

"We pay eight times more than what Ballina pays".

Accused priest denies child sex claims at trial

premium_icon Accused priest denies child sex claims at trial

Catholic priest is accused of abusing two boys in the 1980s

Fed-up dairy farmer predicts demise of Aussie milk

premium_icon Fed-up dairy farmer predicts demise of Aussie milk

"It won't be long before there are milk shortages"

Local Partners