MOVIE REVIEW: Victoria and Abdul's storytelling is a stretch

Judi Dench and Ali Fazal in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul.
Judi Dench and Ali Fazal in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul. Peter Mountain

A LONG time after John Brown... came Abdul Karim.

There are echoes of Queen Victoria's "inappropriate" relationship with her gallant Scottish servant in this autumnal postscript to Mrs Brown (1997), based on the true story of the long-reigning monarch's unlikely friendship with an Indian clerk.


But if the courtiers were upset by the undue influence exerted by one of their own, imagine how they reacted when a Muslim infidel usurped their places in the Queen's affections.

Where the first film, directed by John Madden (Shakespeare In Love, The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel) took a fairly straightforward biographical approach to its subject, Victoria and Abdul plumps for a heightened, quasi-satirical register.

This allows Stephen Frears (The Queen, Philomena) to touch upon some of the potentially ugly ramifications of the story without becoming too entangled by them.

Michael Gambon and Judi Dench in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul.
Michael Gambon and Judi Dench in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul. Peter Mountain

His previous project, Florence Fosters Jenkins, about a tone-deaf heiress who funded her own Carnegie Hall concert, was similarly surface-skimming.

Both films appear more substantial than they are thanks to tour-de-force performances from their heavyweight stars.

Reprising the role of Victoria two decades on, Dench's ageing, disillusioned monarch is every bit as meaty as Meryl Streep's vain, entitled dreamer.

The actresses embrace their characters' flawed humanity so forcefully, their creations teeter, at times, on the edge of grotesque.

When Victoria and Abdul opens, Dench's septuagenarian Queen has pretty much given up the will to live.

In the morning, four or five servants are required to haul the morbidly obese monarch out of bed.

She nods off during official lunches and her table manners are so gluttonous, it's enough to put everybody else off their food.

Abdul (Ali Fazal), who travels from Agra to England to present her with a ceremonial coin, represents novelty and exoticism.

Ali Fazal and Judi Dench in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul.
Ali Fazal and Judi Dench in a scene from the movie Victoria and Abdul. Peter Mountain

In his presence, she rediscovers an appetite for life.

Of course, it helps that the interloper is tall, dark, handsome and extremely charming.

Before long, she has appointed him as her Munshi, or teacher.

The courtiers, who have Abdul pegged as an opportunistic charlatan, are determined to reveal his true colours.

But not even her personal physician's revelation that Abdul is riddled with gonorrhoea causes Victoria to doubt her Munshi.

Audiences are likely to have a few more questions.

The film's re-positioning of Victoria as a racially progressive monarch is also bit of a stretch.

Dench's imperious performance keeps the film afloat, but as a piece of storytelling, Victoria and Abdul is disturbingly glib.

Victoria and Abdul opens on Thursday.


Victoria and Abdul

Stars: Judi Dench, Ali Fazal, Olivia Williams, Michael Gambon, Tim Pigott-Smith.

Director: Stephen Frears

Rating: TBA

Verdict: 2.5 stars


Topics:  judi dench movie review movies victoria and abdul

News Corp Australia

6 tips to avoid getting swooped by magpies

KEEP AN EYE OUT: The change in season means a higher chance of swoops as magpies protect their young.

Humans vs magpies: Here's how to avoid the clash

Would you pay for parking in Brunswick Heads?

Paid parking is being considered for Brunswick Heads

Scheme could generate $900,000 for the council

12 of the best young sports stars on the Northern Rivers

FUTURE STARS: Page MP Kevin Hogan presents nine young Northern Rivers sportsmen and women with certificates and $500 for their achievements.

Remember these faces - they could be famous athletes one day

Local Partners

Pete Evans’ bizarre naked horse photos

CONTROVERSIAL celebrity chef Pete Evans says he was “entirely in the present” after posting bizarre naked horse snaps on his farm with wife Nicola Robinson.

Gogglebox gets new cast members

Gogglebox's new trio — Jad, Sarah Marie and Matty.

Three new cast members to add a “Middle-Eastern flavour”.

Oils fight for Great Barrier Reef

Peter Garrett, from Midnight OIl.

Midnight Oil has announced a concert highlighting damage to the reef

'What a rip-off': Price hike leaves Cowboys fans grounded

Jetstar is one of the airlines that have hiked prices up to Sydney next weekend.

Many Cowboys fans won't be seeing the grand finals next weekend.

Oasis fans discover Liam’s real name

English musician, singer, and songwriter, former lead singer of the rock band Oasis, Liam Gallagher performs during his concert at National Olympic Sports Center in Beijing, China, 10 August 2017.

SINGER has left fans shocked after they uncovered his real name.

Behind the Bee Gees’ spectacular fall

The Bee Gees in their heyday.

IN 1979, the Bee Gees sold out arenas. Then it all went downhill.

Another major blindside on Survivor

Tessa O’Halloran from Australian Survivor.

AN early fan favourite is the latest contestant to be sent packing.