Menu
Entertainment

OPINION: Fresh talent forgotten in reality TV turnstile

The X Factor judges, from left, James Blunt, Guy Sebastian, Dannii Minogue and Chris Isaak. Supplied by Channel 7. Photo by Nicole Hasthorpe.
The X Factor judges, from left, James Blunt, Guy Sebastian, Dannii Minogue and Chris Isaak. Supplied by Channel 7. Photo by Nicole Hasthorpe. Nicole Hasthorpe

THERE is no doubt the music industry is changing at a rapid pace.

Digital charts, downloads, YouTube and Vevo channels and social media all now play key roles in the careers of international artists.

But I don't think our reality singing shows are keeping up with the times.

Really, when you look back there hasn't been a talent show since Australian Idol that has put out a truly successful recording artist.

Several of Idol's finalists and runners-up - think Guy Sebastian, Jessica Mauboy and Matt Corby - are now living out their music dreams.

The four winners of The Voice and the past winners of The X-Factor haven't enjoyed such sustained mainstream success, except for maybe Reece Mastin.

Similarly, Justice Crew is the one musical success story out of the seven seasons of Australia's Got Talent.

The contestants on our current talent shows are treated as such disposable commodities that they're forgotten quickly by the public.

I bet you could name this year's four celebrity mentors on The Voice, but could you name the four singers who made it to the grand final?

It also doesn't help that they're overshadowed by the profiles and personalities of their famous mentors.

Sure, big names attract eyeballs, but when they're given too much attention, they detract from what is supposed to be the primary purpose of these shows - to be a springboard for fresh, raw talent.

Arguments between celebrity mentors on The Voice and, more recently, The X-Factor, have been making the headlines - not the performances by the contestants.

It was frustrating earlier this week to hear James Blunt say his so-called feud with Dannii Minogue on the X-Factor was distracting, and then minutes later see him get into another row with Chris Isaak.

I'm not saying Ten should bring back Idol, but talented young singers need more than just lip service.

Topics:  reality tv singer singing television x factor



Missing swimmer on north coast, search underway

HAZARDOUS SURF: Surf lifesavers are pleading with the public to stay out of the water this weekend after one of the biggest rescue days occurred on Saturday and swimmer is still missing on the north coast.

Hazardous surf warning and one swimmer missing

Ute and truck smash on highway

CRASH RESCUE: At 2am on Sunday the Westpac Life Saver Rescue Helicopter was called out to a crash involving a ute colliding with a truck on the Pacific motorway near Brunswick Heads.

Pacific Highway blocked after ute and truck smash

Ferry return to service delayed

No Caption

Service will not resume as expected

Local Partners

Stone the flamin’ crows: Home and Away actor's new project

HE’S played the iconic Alf Stewart for 30 years — but now, Home and Away’s Ray Meagher is working on a new project.

Audience member shocked penis puppeteer

Rich Binning and Barry Brisco from Puppetry of the Penis.

It takes a lot to shock Rich Binning who appears nude on stage

What’s the greatest 1980s movie ever?

That lift, featuring Patrick Swayze and Jennifer Grey, back when she had a normal nose.

From Dirty Dancing and Crocodile Dundee to Die Hard

Jennifer Lawrence flaunts her nudity on set

Actress Jennifer Lawrence attends the premiere of "Red Sparrow" at the Newseum on Thursday, Feb. 15, 2018, in Washington. (Photo by Brent N. Clarke/Invision/AP)Source:AP

Jennifer Lawrence so comfortable on Red Sparrow set, she went naked

Bardot’s biggest secrets finally revealed

L-R: Belinda Chapple, Tiffany Wood, Sally Polihronas, Sophie Monk and Katie Underwood made up Bardot.

Popstars girl group Bardot’s biggest secrets finally revealed

How three Aussie movie-makers lured Helen Mirren

Jason Clarke and Helen Mirren in a scene from the movie Winchester. Supplied by Studiocanal.

It took a lot of work for three Aussies to lure the Oscar winner

Roxy Jacenko: ‘I came over all hot’

Roxy Jacenko and Oliver Curtis have talked about their sex life since his prison release last year. Picture: Aaron Francis.

The pair gave revealing interview about their lives since his release