War on Woolworths escalates | Northern Rivers News | Local News in Northern Rivers

War on Woolworths escalates

THE latest shots were fired yesterday in the battle against a Woolworths store in Mullumbimby.

A group of Mullumbimby residents is continuing its campaign to stop Woolworths building a supermarket in the town. As part of their campaign they have burnt a Woolworths Effigy at Apex Park in Mullumbimby.

Poll

Should the proposed Woolworths at Mullumbimby go ahead?

THE latest shots were fired yesterday in the battle against a Woolworths store in Mullumbimby.

They were aimed at where it is likely to hurt the company most – its profit and reputation.

Mullumbimby Forum’s renewed campaign against the ‘threat’ the retailer poses to the town consists of letters to senior company officials and its 400,000 shareholders, and a half-page advert in The Australian Financial Review.

The letters contain searching questions, such as whether it would be in the best interests of the shareholders if the ‘might’ of Woolworths prevailed over the ‘right’ of local opinion.

“We ask that you consider potential damage to reputation associated with protracted disputation with the Mullumbimby community, especially given the likely very small financial gains from establishing a store in Mullumbimby,” one letter asks.

“Are such localised conflicts counter-productive, focusing unhelpful attention on Woolies’ market dominance?”

Tricia Shantz, the group’s secretary, said the campaign was ‘holding a mirror up to Woolworths, in the light of its claims that it has a high level of social responsibility’.

“We are asking, ‘What if a community doesn’t want you? Where does your responsibility lie then?’,” Ms Shantz said.

The Forum says it is defending the ‘identity of a unique community’.

Another 1000 or so letters have been written by Mullum residents to the Woolworths chairman, James Strong, and company secretary, Peter Horton, expressing opposition to the supermarket.

The company’s media manager, Benedict Brook, said in a statement: “The site in Mullumbimby was already approved for a supermarket when Woolworths purchased it and the reality is, if we don’t build it then another supermarket operator is likely to.

“We know there is significant demand for a new supermarket as currently people have to drive to Ocean Shores or Brunswick Heads to do the bulk of their shopping. We are moving forward with this new store because we know there is support for it within the Mullum community.”

However, Byron mayor Jan Barham said the chain of events leading to the Land and Environment Court’s approval of the project had not been the ‘healthiest of processes’.

She said the decision – and Byron’s rights – had been taken out of council’s hands by the State Government.

Cr Barham said it was ‘very unlikely’ that the council would appeal against the court’s decision.

“We would be irresponsible to follow that path now,” she said.

“Up to this point we have been absolutely correct to maintain the action. We def- end our planning rules for a good reason.”

 
Lismore Northern Star  

Add a Comment

 

Recent Comments

Add a Comment »

Posted by yambaman from Yamba, New South Wales

16 February 2010 9:16 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

These misguided, anti-Woolies idiots would be well advised to look at what happened at Maleny Qld a few years ago, where a similar "we don't want you" group tried to stop Woolworths from proceeding with a store -the same people are now very happy they failed, they have a top quality store supplying cheaper and better food than previously available and many more employment opportunities for their children!

Posted by Eileen from Maclean, New South Wales

16 February 2010 12:24 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Yep. The local supermarket in Maclean is quite good but a lot of their prices are higher. There is talk about a Woolworths here one day and I'm all for it. Apparently Yamba is replacing BiLo with a Coles this year.

Posted by dr_news from Australia, None

16 February 2010 1:08 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

I saw the same thing happen at Maleny on the Sunshine Coast (albeit without the fire!) when Wooloworths threatened to open there. Protests, stories in the papers, lots of hot air and noise - but the protestors messed up their paperwork and now there's a Woolies at Maleny. Let's hope Mullumbimby spend time on ensuring all their protests don't go to waste.

Posted by jongen from Australia, None

16 February 2010 1:39 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Woolworths no thanks, give an ALDI STORE anyday

Posted by solawiz from Rosebank, New South Wales

16 February 2010 2:18 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Personally I would like the status quo to remain and the little town I visit regularly to be without a dominating Supermarket. The fact that nobody will be able to set up competition to a Woolworth's store is disturbing to say the least. It's like if we only had one bank an no others where allowed in town, it wouldn't be fair. So why don't we have Aldi as well to keep the Bastards honest??? I can remember when Woolies and Coles tried to prevent Aldi from entering Lismore, but there was one in Ballina. What was that all about? I suggest that people band together with sharing fuel and or even have a community bus to take them shopping in either Ballina or Lismore to show the multinational imperialists their backsides and shop where there is competition and fairness which is leaving our small town.

Posted by snapperking from Maroochydore, Queensland

16 February 2010 4 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Sorry dr_news and yambaman. Your remarks about Maleny are simply wrong. Maleny's "We Won't Shop There" campaign is stronger than ever. Car stickers are still selling as quickly as they can be printed at 5000 a time. Woolworths Maleny remains the only Ww supermarket in Australia that does not publish monthly turnover figures in internal company documents. Why? Because hardly anyone shops there. Woolworths has brought very few permanent jobs to Maleny and its prices are generally well above those at the local IGA. However, Woolworths' out-of-date specials are becoming famous. Re Maleny protesters "messing up their paperwork" . Sorry. Quite the contrary. Woolworths and the developer reneged on an offer to sell back the site at the very last minutes, after the community raised an incredible $2.1 million (three times what they paid for it) in two weeks. Woolworths Maleny will be the first to close through low turnover -- an occurrence becoming common with Wal-Mart in the US -- on which Woolworths bases many of its retail policies.

Posted by dr_news from Australia, None

16 February 2010 5:06 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

I've been to Wooloworths at Maleny, and yes it is a ghost town, I agree with you snapperking. The community of Maleny has done very well to boycott it.

But wasn't the whole point of protest to save the platypus which would be affected by the building of a Woolworths on/near their habitat?

Well, that didn't work, because it's been built. And that wont' change no matter how many car stickers you sell.

Posted by snapperking from Maroochydore, Queensland

16 February 2010 6:03 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Thanks dr_news. The widely publicised platpus habitat was only one of many reasons Maleny opposed Woolworths. Residents are working on what remains of the creek bank beside Woolworths, re-establishing native trees and have been rewarded by sighting several platypus. They may be wanderers... or perhaps locals that have adjusted to having metre-wide concrete pylons poured into their burrows. No, some of us will never shop there.

Posted by greenfields from Mullumbimby Creek, New South Wales

16 February 2010 8:21 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

'We know there is significant demand for a new supermarket as currently people have to drive to Ocean Shores or Brunswick Heads to do the bulk of their shopping.'
You are kidding of course, Mr Media Manager, Benedict Brook! Locals shop locally in Mullumbimby. That is what community is all about. That is what our community is all about.

Perhaps you do not understand what community actually means - which is why you are imposing this juggernaut on our small rural community.

Listen and learn...you don't know what warmth and wealth (real wealth) you are missing out on.

Posted by DinkyTwist from Australia, None

17 February 2010 9:37 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Local Local Local....
We are at peak everything fellow Mullumbimbyites. Unless we become self sufficient we will be at the effect of the soon to be massive fuel : food price increase. Lets produce more and more here and become independant and prosperous. Use the future ex Woolies site to expand the Mullum Community Gardens. Woolies is inevitably unsustainable. 1,000 calories on my plate cost 10,000 calories to get there. We all know that cant keep going. Lets develop our own sustainable self sufficient community. Thats where our children's future is.

Posted by DinkyTwist from Australia, None

17 February 2010 10:25 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

I'm not anti Wollies Yambaman. I really enjoy the range and prices too. But I truly believe that in the very near future self sufficiency and independance will be essential to our quality of life. The foundation of our global economic systems and corporations are shaking. Our sustainability and security is in the development of local resources especially food and energy.

Posted by Richy from Mullumbimby Creek, New South Wales

17 February 2010 12:50 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Dear yambaman and your woolworths loving friends, for a moment open your mind and consider whether your hip pocket nerve is being fooled by your corporate giant. Are you really getting a good deal? Have a look at a list of the top 100 Woolworths shareholders and you won't find any Aussie mums and dads. Number one shareholder is HSBC- Hong Kong And Shanghai Banking Corporation, do you think they have any other motive than extracting every possible cent out of your pocket and the local community. Do you think that the big share holders of the Woolworths corporate have a single moral bone in their bodies? Do you think the good people that once controlled the big Aussie company still have any power? That time has past, Woolworths is controlled by array of other corporate giants, Aussie mum's and dad shareholders have lost any power to do good.

Posted by daggett from Red Hill, Queensland

17 February 2010 4:36 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Good on you for standing up to Woolworths.

If Governments continue to disregard the clear wishes of local residents as they have in Maleny, in Kyogle and Tweed shires with the Repco Rally last September and now, it seems, in Mullumbimby, then we are no longer a democracy in any real sense.

It's time the corporate glove puppets who who are supposed to be representing us in our Parliaments and councils were thrown out of office and, ideally, put behind bars for what they have done.

Posted by mullumjenni from Mullumbimby Creek, New South Wales

18 February 2010 11:13 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

A recent survey showed that Australians pay the highest prices for their groceries. Can we thank our powerful duopoloy -Woolworths and Coles for that?
We desperately need to cut greenhouse emissions and reduce our dependancy on fossil fuels. These big corporations truck food great distances because they never or very rarely buy locally produced food. Their distribution is organised in a centralized way.
Their usual mode of operation is to temporarily drive prices down until the local small family businesses (which is the case for most shops in of our friendly town) cannot compete and go out of business. Then they put their prices up again. Then we gradually get a virtual ghost town in our main street and/or characterless chain stores who take the profits off to Sydney or overseas. The opposite is the multiplier effect- where money spent in your town cycles through all the businesses in town and everyone prospers. Wollies will cause more job loss that job creation and amenity loss and I haven't even mentioned traffic snarls in tiny streets.
I really don't want a Woolworths, but I am looking forward to the Growers Market starting in Mullum soon.

Posted by india from Australia, None

19 February 2010 9:35 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Woolworths the "Fresh Food People". Surely they could be charged under the trade descriptions act?

Everythings picked unripe and gassed and/or preserved then shipped!

At a grower's market you get to meet the local farmers and get a feel/taste for your produce direct from the farm. And hopefully, organic certified or chemical free.

Posted by Voice from Ballina, New South Wales

19 February 2010 10:32 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

If not Woolworths it will eventually be something else. One day these protesters will be on their death beds and wondering why they wasted their days battling against something they essentially will not win. Get over it guys and move on or move away.

Posted by india from Australia, None

19 February 2010 5:10 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

One day these protesters will be telling inspiring stories to their children/grandchildren about how they stood up for their principles. Voice, you might listen too and hopefully not regret standing up for yours.

Posted by Dessyp from Grafton, New South Wales

20 February 2010 8:48 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

in the naysayers are so confident that woolworths aren't wanted, then just let them relax and watch them go down the gurgler, due to a lack of customers....!

Posted by lovethebuzz from Mullumbimby Creek, New South Wales

20 February 2010 9:20 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Its a dilema for a resident.... The "old world" charm of a thriving country town vs the practicality of living on a budget. A shopping basket comparion I recently personally did between IGA Mullum and IGA Byron resulted at $20 extra in Mullumbimby for an $80 shopping basket. The existing options for groceries in Mullumbimby are ample but the business owners seem to be taking advantage of the hostage populus and also seem to specialise in providing employment for minnimum age checkout personel probably at minnimum wage. So why is it more expensive to shop at the same supermarket chain in Mullumbimby? At the 25% margin the existing grocery retailers are taking they should be able to survive if the nimby's support their chosen existing vendors regardless of the branding of any new competitor.

Posted by Mullumite from Mullumbimby Creek, New South Wales

20 February 2010 2:28 p.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

The pole you are running is totally unfair to most people in this town and out lying areas,the rent a crowd that has shown up over the last two weeks (don't even know the name of the main street)are up to the usual tricks, giving out letters to send to Woolworths to school children and tourist with no connection to this town, I was in Maleny two weeks ago the Woolworths was thriving .
,speaking to the locals they said it was the best thing that happened in the town, These "I'm against everything "crowd know this, yet they publish the pack of lies. My family were here for Christmas and were astounded at the cost of living here,no wonder we all go out of town to shop. By the way in my Street no one buys the Star and there are only two computors so caan you consider this a fair pole
,

Posted by jedda from Main Arm, New South Wales

24 March 2010 8:43 a.m. | Suggest removal » | Post reply »

Woolworths will kill Mullum
it will kill the community
it will kill property prices
it will kill local business
And surprise surprise it wont give a damn... its already shown us in its campaign to establish itself here that what we want or need doesn't count!
Any one who believes otherwise is misguided!
SELFISH CORPORATE GIANT WILL STOMP ALL OVER US!

Add a Comment

 
  • Late shower

    Today

    Late shower

    14°C/25°C
  • Rain

    Tomorrow

    Rain

    16°C/25°C

Northern Rivers forecast »

Special offers
Leo

24 July - 23 August

Perhaps you've placed too much focus on one person and have not received the love and attention that you'd expected in return. This experience is only going to... More Horoscopes »

Select your zodiac sign

Aries | Taurus | Gemini | Cancer | Leo | Virgo | Libra | Scorpio | Sagittarius | Capricorn | Aquarius | Pisces

Things To Do

What's On

Browse

 

powered by

Link to top
APN news and media

© APN News & Media Ltd 2010. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited under the laws of Australia and by international treaty. APN | APN Group Websites

Back to access links