News

Rous head ‘should resign’ over fluoride, says campaigner

Anti-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack
Anti-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack Jacklyn Wagner

ANTI-fluoride campaigner Al Oshlack has called on the head of Rous Water to resign over confusion around the question of a legal requirement to fluoridate the region's water supply.

Mr Oshlack said instead of chasing him to pay the estimated $300,000 in costs awarded to Rous following his loss in the NSW Court of Appeal last month on his bid to stop the construction of five fluoride-dousing plants, Rous general manager Kyme Lavelle should quit.

Mr Oshlack said his opinion was that Mr Lavelle had a moral and ethical responsibility to resign.

His comment came yesterday after he had decided not to appeal the case further.

However, Mr Lavelle responded by telling The Northern Star he took his position seriously and stood by the process Rous followed.

"Council acted in accordance with legal advice which covered a range of issues including directions and

How The Northern Star broke the story of Rous councillors who were told they could face legal action if they voted against fluoridation.
How The Northern Star broke the story of Rous councillors who were told they could face legal action if they voted against fluoridation.

approvals from the State Government," he said.

"Only part of that advice was challenged and council successfully defended four out of five grounds of appeal.

"The one ground on which council was not successful was held by the court not to have any consequence for the validity of council's assessment and decision-making process."

Mr Lavelle tabled the legal advice just before councillors voted on fluoridation in April 2010. Chairman Philip Silver used his casting vote to pass the motion five to four.

Voting intentions changed dramatically following the tabling of the advice that said councillors would be personally liable for fines until fluoridation was approved.

At the time councillor David Yarnall, who changed his vote based on the advice, said: "I find this extremely distressing as it takes away our democratic rights. I unfortunately feel we have no alternative at this stage."

While the NSW Appeals court found against the bid to stop the plants, it did find the legal advice was erroneous, but it didn't invalidate the vote by Rous councillors.

Topics:  fluoride, rous water




Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

3 easy dinner recipes your kids will love, and so will you

No Caption

THERE is a middle ground! Dinners fit for kids and adults.

How to reduce your child's risk of food allergies

ABOUT 90% of food allergies are caused by just seven foods.

5 good mental health habits for kids (and parents)

CRYING OUT FOR HELP: The demand for counselling support for children and young people is increasing.

FORMING good habits early is critical for your child's mental health.

Smack or no smack - where do you stand?

THE debate is reignited - is smacking acceptable?

Susie O'Neill: Why I stopped smacking my children

Swimming legend Susie O'Neill says she has stopped smacking her kids.

“I (smacked) because that’s what I knew growing up."

Introducing a step-parent into the family

Introducing a step-parent into the family can be stressful for the children, as well as the new parent.

THERE is no easy way to introduce a step parent into the family.

It’s windy out there: Gusts of more than 70km/h

Denon Minnikin, 13, of Alstonville, is swept away by high winds.

INTENSE gusts of wind are battering the region

VIDEO: Police reveal 100kg hydroponic weed haul

Drugs seized after raids at Nimbin and Lennox Head.

VIDEO AND PHOTOS: Properties at Lennox Head, Nimbin raided by police

10-year-old girl rushed to hospital after being hit by bus

Paramedics are rushing to an incident in which a person has been hit by a vehicle.

Emergency services are treating a student who has been hit by a bus

Latest deals and offers

Justice Lucy McCallum

Justice Lucy McCallum

Justice Lucy McCallum says she reduced Oliver Curtis's sentence due to comments...

$1 million cannabis seizure

Police discuss a huge cannabis seizure and the arrest of seven men.

Perisher has 50cm of snow

Resort to open after 50cm of snow.

Smiggin Holes and Blue Cow to open after 50cm of snaow falls in Perisher valley.

OPINION: Should we give up the great Aussie dream?

Generic housing Rural View.

First home buyers are struggling big time

Commercial Property June 16 edition

SNAPPED UP: A sushi shop in a106sq mground-floor tenancy with a 43sq moutdoor area in Southport Central Towers on the Gold Coast has sold for $954,000.

RealCommercial edition June 16, 2016.

Iconic North Coast hotel could sell for $80 million

ON THE MARKET: The Beach Hotel, Byron Bay.

Million-dollar views, good income, beer - what more could you want?