News

'God' defence rejected

A downstairs extension to this South Golden Beach house will have to be pulled down on the orders of Mullumbimby Local Court.
A downstairs extension to this South Golden Beach house will have to be pulled down on the orders of Mullumbimby Local Court. Mireille Merlet-Shaw

A MOTHER and daughter told a court only God had the authority to order them to pull down an illegal extension to their South Golden Beach property, but the magistrate took a different view.

In a hearing at Mullumbimby Local Court on Thursday, Byron Shire Council argued the downstairs area of the property was not approved to live in as part of the original development consent and it should be demolished.

The council's governance manager, Ralph James, said despite several requests over the past two years, the property owner had not taken any reasonable steps to get the downstairs development approved or cease use of the area.

"Of concern was the fact that the house was located in an area that is subject to flooding," he said.

"The closed-in downstairs area was 1.6m below the Council's flood planning level, and 0.7m below the level of the flood that occurred in 2005."

The shire argued the pair breached the Building Code of Australia by using poor quality brackets on a rear veranda extension, no complying handrails on the stairs and no smoke detectors on the lower part of the property.

The council was originally notified of the illegal extensions by a community member and the matter was listed for December 1, 2011 but the defendants failed to attend.

When the matter was heard, the women submitted a written argument stating they did not have to submit to the jurisdiction of the court, or the council

God was only jurisdiction they recognised, she told the court.

Southern Cross University lecturer in the school of law and justice, Warwick Fisher, said it was an unusual defence.

"It's a strict rule of Australian government that the church and state are separate. The church deals with spiritual matters and the state makes laws regarding its citizens and that includes land law," he said.

The magistrate found against the pair, fining them a total $6000 and ordering they pay the council's professional costs of $3000.

Mr James said it was a signal to property owners to seek council development approval.

Topics:  court, god, illegal, magistrate




Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Bangalow needs win to remain a threat to soccer leaders

Jono Pierce was tireless in the attack for Byron Bay in a 1-all draw against Lismore Workers in Football Far North Coast premier league.

Bangalow needs home win to remain a threat in FNC soccer.

Strange Politics: Barnaby gets carp help from Trump

This was not why you got into the espionage industry.

YOUR THOUGHTS: Many agree NBN rollout is ‘second rate’

The NBN has been rolled out to several parts of the North Burnett.  Photo Tobi Loftus / Central & North Burnett Times

Readers share thoughts about the North Coast NBN rollout.

Latest deals and offers

Tribute to readers mums

Jess Ind and her mum.

Tribute to readers mums

Federal Police Defuse Dance Bomb

Australian Federal Police respond to "threat" in Canberra.

Australian Federal Police respond to "threat" in Canberra.

Tribute to mums

Jess Ind and her mum.

Readers pics and their thoughts on their mums

How a sacked real estate agent made $725k in four months

Agent is now under investigation by the industry watchdog

10 ‘must-see’ open homes on the Northern Rivers this weekend

McGrath Ballina have listed this home at 19 Stonehenge Place, Lennox Head.

Looking for a new home? Then check out this list.

VIDEO: Art Deco fan pays $835,000 for Imperial Hotel

No Caption

Iconic "Impy" sold at a bargan price to bidder who loves Art Deco.